Pensions in the Age of Market Uncertainty – Avoiding Trapped Surplus

Discover how pension deficit escrows offer a low-cost, efficient solution to avoid trapped surplus in defined benefit schemes amid market volatility.
Pensions in the Age of Market Uncertainty – Avoiding Trapped Surplus
Specialist Escrow & Payment Services
Subscribe to our newsletter
We've added you to our mailing list.  You can unsubscribe at any time from the footer of every email.
Please try again, ensuring that you enter a valid email address.

Why are pension deficit escrows relevant again?

The defined benefit pension landscape is once again under scrutiny, as volatile market conditions compel sponsors and trustees to reassess their funding strategies. For solicitors advising corporate clients, the challenge is clear: how to meet funding obligations without exposing the business to the long-term risk of overfunding and the consequential issue of trapped surplus.

While pension deficit escrows were last in vogue during the post-2008 and 2015 economic turbulence, they are enjoying renewed interest. As equity markets fluctuate and gilt yields remain volatile, some schemes may show temporary deficits that prompt pressure on sponsors to 'top up' funding. However, if markets subsequently recover, these top-up contributions risk becoming unrecoverable surplus - effectively trapping capital that could have remained strategically deployable.

What is a pension deficit escrow?

A pension deficit escrow is a financial arrangement that allows a sponsoring employer to set aside funds in a segregated account to be used towards a pension scheme’s deficit. Crucially, these funds remain under the employer’s control until a predefined trigger - such as agreement by the scheme trustees or the outcome of a valuation - allows release to the scheme.

This mechanism permits rapid deployment of funds if needed while ensuring that, should the deficit narrow or disappear, the sponsor can reclaim the escrowed capital without the complexities and costs of surplus recovery.

Why should advisors consider recommending escrow to clients?

Advisors advising on corporate transactions, refinancing, or pension negotiations are uniquely placed to recommend escrow as an elegant solution to the thorny issue of contingent pension funding. Escrow offers multiple strategic benefits:

  • Speed: Escrow arrangements can typically be established in a matter of days, unlike the drawn-out process of formal funding negotiations or insurance-led solutions.
  • Cost-efficiency: Establishing an escrow incurs minimal setup and operational costs, especially compared to the administrative and legal expenses associated with reclaiming surplus or negotiating funding alterations post hoc.
  • Low opportunity cost: While some argue that holding funds in escrow may yield lower returns than active corporate investment, this must be weighed against the risk of creating an unrecoverable surplus. In most cases, the financial drag of escrow is negligible compared to the strategic flexibility it affords.
  • Preservation of control: Unlike contributions made directly into a pension scheme, escrowed funds remain the legal property of the sponsor until the agreed release mechanism is triggered. This avoids the regulatory and fiduciary entanglements that typically accompany surplus disputes.

Regulatory and actuarial support

The use of escrow arrangements has received positive consideration from regulators, including The Pensions Regulator (TPR), particularly when applied as part of a contingent funding arrangement. Moreover, leading actuarial consultancies have long endorsed escrow for its ability to balance prudence with flexibility.

From a legal perspective, escrow also provides clarity and insulation. Provided that the terms are clearly drafted and the structure complies with the statutory funding objective, there is little to obstruct its adoption. Solicitors must, however, ensure that the escrow agreement is bespoke to the client’s needs, particularly regarding trigger events, duration, and any conditions for release or reversion.

Why now?

Today’s market presents a confluence of factors that make escrow particularly appealing. Many schemes are approaching full funding, creating anxiety about locked-in capital. Meanwhile, macroeconomic instability underscores the need for flexibility and liquidity. For sponsors who wish to demonstrate commitment without forfeiting optionality, escrow is not merely an option - it is a strategic asset.

With trustees increasingly open to creative funding approaches and regulatory frameworks allowing for contingent support mechanisms, solicitors have a critical role in bringing these solutions to the fore.

A professional solution for discerning clients

The pension deficit escrow service offered by trusted institutions such as DOS & Co. represents a tailored, professionally managed solution that aligns with best-practice governance and legal rigour. By providing an independent, regulated escrow structure, such services ensure transparency, compliance, and ease of execution.

What is of particular interest to trustees and employers alike is the fact that all funds are kept ring-fenced and safeguarded at the Bank of England - protecting them in the longer term against any risk of insolvency of the escrow provider or the underlying banking institution - funds that we hold in escrow are not loaned out on anyone's balance sheet. For the operators of larger schemes, with deficits in the tens or even hundreds of millions, the importance of this for a longer-term escrow arrangement cannot be overstated.

Clients benefit not only from the ability to satisfy trustee concerns promptly but also from the reputational value of demonstrating responsible stewardship. For solicitors seeking to offer clients a credible, low-friction mechanism to navigate pension funding challenges, escrow stands out as both technically sound and commercially compelling.

Conclusion: Legal certainty in uncertain times

As the defined benefit pensions sector contends with renewed economic unpredictability, the need for innovative, flexible funding solutions has never been greater. Pension deficit escrows offer solicitors a practical tool to help clients avoid the pitfalls of trapped surplus while retaining strategic control over their capital.

Their speed of implementation, cost-efficiency, and legal clarity position them as the go-to choice for forward-looking sponsors. In an era defined by volatility, certainty is a luxury—and escrow can deliver it.

Our Escrow Accounts
Discover our Escrow Accounts
Our Third-Party Managed Accounts
Discover our Third-Party Managed Accounts
No items found.

FCA-Regulated

We're regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority for the provision of payment services.

Digital Accounts Portal

Access your account, view your transactions and documents and provide read-only access to all of your relevant stakeholders.

White-Glove Service

Your named account manager can help you manage your accounts at any time, by email, phone or WhatsApp.

High-Speed Account Opening

We can open escrow accounts in as little as a day - our systems and processes are built for speed.

Ultra-Secure Deposits

We deposit all pound sterling sums at the Bank of England, offering the lowest-risk escrow service in the United Kingdom.

Any duration, any value

We can hold funds for as little as a few hours, for many years, or even longer depending on your specific requirements.

What our clients say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our clients who have added trust and security to their escrow and payment requirements.
dospay Escrow & Payments

Articles

Information, guides and blogs about specialist escrow and payment services.